Working 9 to 5 isn’t working

In our parents and grandparents world, the work day starts at 9 and ends at 5. No ifs, ands or buts.

mad men

Today we live in a new world. Free lancing, remote working agreements, part-time, working from home, and online entrepreneurship have changed the name of the game. The nature of work is fundamentally different, yet our society’s work hours and styles remain the same.

Everything about the 9 to 5 schedule is entirely arbitrary – the start and end time, the amount of time, and what we are expected to produce within that set amount of time. This traditional formula is an antiquated ritual, a thing of the past.

Let’s take a look into why we have 8 hour work days in the first place.

ford

During the Industrial Revolution, companies ran their factories 24/7 in order to maximize output. Putting people to work 10-16 hours a day was the norm. One day, Henry Ford implemented the 8 hour work day as a means to increase efficiency amongst his over-exhausted employees. Ford’s profit margins doubled in two years, and suddenly, a new standard was adopted.

And that’s where work place innovation ended. Our 8 hour work days are not designed to meet maximum efficiency, adapt to our prime energy levels or enhance employee productivity. Rather, they are based on a century old norm for running efficient factories.

time clock

Every person’s productivity clock is different. Do you know anyone that can sit still, think and work for 8 hours straight? On a given day, we all only have about 5 hours of ‘superbly productive’ work time. They  typically occur in spurts of 90-120 minutes, with 20-30 minute breaks in between to renew energy and prepare for the next task. The rest of our work day is typically filled with lower-level thinking tasks and procrastination techniques. In essence, how long a person works everyday has NOTHING to do with how productive they actually are.

In Tim Ferris’s “The 4-hour Work Week,” we begin to understand just how arbitrary the founding principles of the 8 hour work week really are. The premise of the book is that working efficiently, even for a few brief hours, can exponentially expand your productivity. Ferris discusses Parkinsons Law, which asserts that the amount of time that one has to perform a task = the amount of time it will take to complete the task.

In other words, if we have 5 days to write a report, then we will fill all 5 days to complete it. If we have 3 hours, we will finish it in 3 hours. And guess what? More often than not, the 3-hour report will be better than the 5-day report. Ferris explains how fewer hours and fewer days on the job will make you more efficient with your time. More on Ferris and the book in a later post…

So why do we see such an absurd incongruity between work place practices and the way we actually operate?

Until recently (in evolutionary terms) we as humans have been motivated by one simple and all-consuming task: survival. Motivation 1.0, as coined by Daniel Pink in “Drive”, refers to our ancestral drive to do whatever it takes to make it through the day and pass on our genes to our offspring. Food, security, sex… repeat.

darwin

Next came the Industrial Revolution, and with that, Motivation 2.0. This form of drive  operates under the assumption that all work consists of simple, uninteresting tasks, and the only way to get people to undertake these tasks is to properly incentivize and carefully monitor all the little worker-bees.

workplace

In essence, to ensure ultimate productivity amongst your employees, you must rewards behavior you seek and punish behavior you discourage – also known as the carrot-and-stick approach. This theory assumes, as Pink notes, that “human beings aren’t much different from horses – that the way to get us moving in the right direction is by dangling a crunchier carrot or wielding a sharper stick.”

carrot stick

But jobs of the 21st century have changed dramatically. They are more complex and more interesting. For most of us, they require more lateral thinking, self-direction and creativity. Traditional stick and carrots of Motivation 2.0 simply aren’t doing the job. In fact, they do more harm than good. Motivation 2.0 in the world of work force 3.0 has proven to lower performance, banish creativity and encourage short term thinking.

In short: we need an upgrade.

Enter Motivaton 3.0. Encapsulating the power of intrinsic motivation (read: motivation from within), Motivation 3.0 presumes that humans are most driven by their desire to learn, to create and to better the world.

Today, many companies are employing an interesting tactic called ROWE (Results oriented work environment). ROWE provides employees the freedom to come and leave as they please as long as tasks are completed. Statically speaking, this focus on output rather than schedule strategy has proven to increase productivity and overall satisfaction.

Rowe1

ROWE is just one method of many based on self-determination theory (STD). STD proposes that human beings have an innate drive to practice self-determination (autonomy) and be connected to one another, to learn and create new things (mastery) and most importantly, to do better by ourselves and our world, according to our own terms (purpose.) When this third drive is liberated, people achieve more and live richer lives.

It’s time we all enter the 21st century. The nature of work has changed. The only thing left is an antiquated system which we keep in place because we are too scared to operate otherwise.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Working 9 to 5 isn’t working

  1. Kill 9-to-5! In my own job I strive for a ROWE approach. I learned about it first from Tim Ferriss’s The 4-Hour Work Week. There’s just so much you can do in some jobs, though. So, I turned to fiction, and wrote a novel about a cubicle dweller putting Ferriss’s principles to work. If you’re interested, you can read the first chapter here: http://jfhussey.com/the-4-hour-novel/. Hope you like it. Cheers, John Hussey

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s